Wherebly Wherebly.
  • Home
  • Cities
  • Stories
  • How It Works
  • For Restaurants
  • About
Help Share a place
Home › United States › California › San Diego › Mr. Frostie › Menu

Mr. Frostie menu.

Explore the Mr. Frostie menu featuring creamy frostys, frozen treats, and classic desserts. Located on Garnet Ave, San Diego, enjoy quality flavors like pistachio, salted caramel, and mango pineapple swirl at great prices with friendly service.

— Week of 23 Mar, 2026 —
Specialty Shakes 13 All American 8 Frozen Goodies 2 Other Delicious Foo 7 Others 12
about this week's card —

About the menu

Introducing the menu at Mr. Frostie, an inviting ice cream and dessert haven located on Garnet Ave, San Diego. This spot offers a delightful array of specialty shakes, from rich Oreo and indulgent Brownie Bites to unique flavors like Red Velvet and Peanut Butter. Their frozen treats extend beyond shakes, featuring refreshing Frozen Bananas and classic Drumsticks, perfect for warm days.

Beyond frozen delights, Mr. Frostie offers toppings and add-ons such as chocolate syrup, fresh strawberries, waffle cones, and Spanish peanuts, enhancing each dessert's texture and taste. Whether you crave a creamy vanilla scoop or a tangy pineapple twist, every option feels thoughtfully crafted.

What truly stands out is the balance—generous portions that don’t oversweeten, yet excite the palate. The cozy, bustling vibe complements the fast, friendly service, making it an ideal family stop. Mr. Frostie’s menu strikes a perfect harmony between quality, variety, and affordability, leaving you eager to explore every flavor.

Allergies or dietary restrictions? Please ask staff before ordering — they can talk you through every dish. Menus change often, so symbols aren't always up to date.
from the pass —

Menu photos

A few dishes from the current card — tap any shot to view larger.

Menu Photo 1
Menu Photo 2
Menu Photo 3
Menu Photo 4
Menu Photo 5
Menu Photo 6
Menu Photo 7
Menu Photo 8
Menu Photo 9
Menu Photo 10
1 / 10

Specialty Shakes

13 items

Oreo

Choc Cake Batter

Peanut Butter

Heath

Reese's

Brownie Bites

Butterfinger

Yellow Cake Batter

Hot Fudge

Raspberry

Red Velvet

Blueberry

Cookie Dough

All American

8 items

Whipped Cream

Chocolate Frosty

Vanilla Frosty

Hot Fudge

Butterscotch

Marshmallow

Chocolate Chips

Bananas

Frozen Goodies

2 items

Frozen Banana

Drumsticks

Other Delicious Foo

7 items

Hot Dog

Corn Dog

Chili Dog

Bowl Of Chili

Potato Chips

Potato Salad

Soft Drinks

Others

12 items

Chocolate Syrup

Strawberries

Pineapple

Banana Tub

Waffle Cone

Hot Chocolate

Strawberry

Spanish Peanuts

Vanilla

Chocolate

Peanuts

Lemonade

from a recent review —
It’s a rare and wonderful day to have a delicious dessert that is inexpensive without feeling cheap. This is a true spot to take the family and everybody comes away happy. There will almost certainly be a line, but it moves fast, so not much waiting. And it’s a great vibe. Walk to the counter, order, pay, and grab your food at the next. The place is almost always bumping, so it’s unlikely you’ll be able to sit down. Honestly though, you’re in PB. There are almost limitless numbers of excellent places to walk.
Benjamin Williams
Mar 11, 2026
ready to visit —

Plan your visit.

Opening hours, the full address and the best way to get there are all on the restaurant page. Booking policies differ from place to place — so call ahead, or simply walk in.

View overview Call +1 858-274-9977
WhereblyWherebly.

A friendly guide to neighbourhood restaurants — written by the people who actually eat there.

Explore
  • Cities
  • Stories
  • Homepage
  • Submit a place
Community
  • How it works
  • Manifesto
  • Contact
For places
  • For restaurants
  • Brand page
Company
  • About
  • Help
  • Privacy
  • Terms
© Wherebly · Hand-edited in 17 cities · Never advertised
Made for people who eat more than they post.